Mabel Idella Bickford Simmons

Her Story Still Unfolds
January 21, 1877 – October 14, 1926
Heritage Memory Quilt block honoring Mabel Idella Bickford Simmons

Mabel Idella Bickford Simmons left behind no simple, tidy story. Her life stretches from a little girl in a blended Maine household to a young wife and mother in Lawrence, Massachusetts; from widowhood and loss to a weathered old house beside the Kennebec River.

The records preserve dates, names, court entries, and changing households. Family memory preserved something different: questions, whispered stories, and a woman remembered long after those who knew her were gone. This page keeps both—carefully labeled, neither discarded nor confused with the other.

“The papers give us facts. The family gives them a heartbeat.”

Her Beginning

Gardiner roots, the Bickford name, and the Thaxter household

Mabel was born January 21, 1877, in Gardiner, Maine, the daughter of Jacob Purington Bickford Sr. and Mary Ann Johnson. By the 1880 census, three-year-old Mabel was living in Augusta with her mother and her stepfather, Charles F. Thaxter. The census identifies her plainly as his stepdaughter.

Later family research says that Mabel sometimes used the surname Thaxter. The 1880 household explains why that name might have followed her, but it does not by itself prove that she formally adopted or consistently used it. In the records gathered for this page, her given name is spelled Mabel with one l.

Young portrait identified as Mabel Idella Bickford Simmons
A family portrait identified as Mabel, photographed at the Reed studio on Main and Cumberland Streets in Brunswick, Maine, circa 1893.
1880 census page showing Mabel Bickford as stepdaughter in the Charles Thaxter household
The 1880 census places three-year-old Mabel in the Charles F. Thaxter household and records her relationship as stepdaughter.

A Young Wife and Mother

Lawrence, Massachusetts — a growing family at the turn of the century

Mabel married Charles Alton Simmonds/Simmons about 1893. The 1900 census found the family in Lawrence, Massachusetts. Charles was a brass worker; Mabel was twenty-three. They reported that they had been married seven years and that Mabel had borne four children, all four living.

Those four children—Mabel, George, Charles, and Eva—appear together in the household. The census also preserves the shifting family spelling: the enumerator wrote the surname as Simmonds, while later records more often used Simmons.

1900 Lawrence Massachusetts census showing Charles and Mabel Simmonds with four children
Lawrence, 1900: Charles and Mabel with Mabel, George, Charles, and Eva—four children born and four living.

Loss and Widowhood

1906 changed the shape of the Simmons household

Charles Alton Simmons died September 26, 1906. Their young son Charles Jr. also died in 1906. The following year, the Lawrence city directory listed Mabel I. Simmons, widow of Charles A., living at 9 Saunders Court.

By 1910 Mabel was the widowed head of her Lawrence household. That census carries one of the strongest clues in her family story: she reported eight children born and five living. The five children in her home were Mabel Charlesina, George, Eva, Raymond, and Clyde.

1907 Lawrence directory listing Mabel I Simmons widow of Charles A
The 1907 Lawrence directory records Charles’s 1906 death and lists Mabel I. Simmons as his widow.
1910 Lawrence census showing widowed Mabel Simmons and five children
In 1910, Mabel reported eight children born and five living—a small set of numbers that helped identify the children missing from the household.

The Children She Carried

Eight before 1910—and one more child whose own beginning became a mystery

Mabel CharlesinaLiving in 1910
GeorgeLiving in 1910
Charles Jr.Died in 1906
EvaLiving in 1910
RaymondLiving in 1910
ClydeLiving in 1910
EvelynTwin born in 1908
EverettTwin born in 1908
Clifton Earl “Skip” SimmonsBorn April 17, 1915—after the 1910 census count
Why the census matters: The 1900 schedule says four children were born and all four were living. Ten years later, Mabel reported eight born and five living. Taken together with the records for Charles Jr. and the twins, those entries allow the family to account for all eight children born before 1910. Skip’s birth came five years later.

Unfinished Threads

When the surviving documents disagree, the disagreement belongs in the story

The twins Evelyn and Everett were born in Lawrence in 1908, two years after Charles Alton Simmons’s death. A Lawrence birth register names their mother as Mabel Bickford and their father as Napoleon Lanctot. Yet their Simmons death records reportedly name Charles A. Simmons as father. Those statements cannot all be literally correct, and the surviving paper trail does not yet resolve the conflict.

An entry in the 1913 Massachusetts marriage index for a Mabel Lanctot in Lawrence is another lead, but an index entry alone cannot establish that she was this Mabel. It is preserved here as a question—not promoted into a conclusion.

Mabel’s youngest son carried a mystery of his own. The original record for a child born April 17, 1915, in Randolph, Maine, names the baby Harold Spencer and gives Mabel Simmons as his mother. In later records and throughout his life, he was known as Clifton Earl “Skip” Simmons. The name change and his paternity remain part of the family’s continuing research.

View the unresolved 1913 Lawrence index entry
1913 Massachusetts marriage index page containing a Mabel Lanctot entry in Lawrence
A 1913 Lawrence marriage-index entry in the name Mabel Lanctot. It remains a research lead rather than proof of identity.

A Genealogist’s Promise

These records are not forced into a smoother story than they can support. Names, fathers, and relationships are recorded as the documents give them, and unanswered questions remain honestly unanswered.

The Stories That Followed Her

Family lore, a house with a reputation, and the record that survives

What the family remembered

Family tradition says that Mabel was a madam or that she operated a bordello. The details have blurred as the story passed from one generation to the next, and no record found so far proves that claim. It remains family lore—important enough to preserve, but not to present as established fact.

What the records do show is that Mabel’s house at Britt’s Gully drew official attention in 1924. She was charged with illegal possession of intoxicating liquor after deputies found five one-gallon jugs containing strong home-brewed beer on the stairway leading to the attic.

Mabel pleaded not guilty and denied selling liquor. She said the beer belonged to a son who was away from Augusta. When officials spoke of complaints about noise around the house, Mabel explained that groups of girls crossed the frozen river to spend evenings playing tiddlywinks there. The judge found her guilty, fined her $100, and sentenced her to two months in jail, with additional time if the fine was not paid. She appealed and was released on her own recognizance for the Superior Court term.

The liquor case does not prove the family’s bordello story. It does, however, place Mabel in the house at Britt’s Gully and shows that stories and complaints already surrounded the place during her lifetime. It may be one of the real events around which later family lore gathered.

1924 newspaper account of the liquor case against Mabel Simmons
The newspaper’s detailed account of the 1924 liquor charge—including Mabel’s memorable explanation about girls crossing the ice to play tiddlywinks.
Augusta municipal court docket for Mabel Simmons in the 1924 liquor case
The municipal-court docket records the charge, guilty finding, sentence, appeal, and $500 personal recognizance.

Back Beside the Kennebec

Augusta, the Old Britt House, and Mabel’s final years

By 1920 Mabel was again in Augusta, Maine, heading her own household. Her children Raymond, Eva, and four-year-old Clifton appear with her. The census is the bridge between the Lawrence years and the Old Britt House—the weathered riverside home named in the accounts of her death.

The Old Britt House was remembered locally as one of Augusta’s oldest structures. By the time Mabel lived there, it had accumulated a reputation of its own. Records place her there in 1924 and again at the end of her life in 1926. The house later burned in 1935, but its image—and the stories attached to it—survived.

1920 Augusta Maine census showing Mabel Simmons with Raymond Eva and Clifton
Augusta, 1920: Mabel at the head of her household with Raymond, Eva, and young Clifton.

Her Final Chapter

The Old Britt House, a family funeral, and Mount Hope Cemetery

Mabel died at the Old Britt House on Thursday, October 14, 1926, aged forty-nine. One death notice described an illness of three months; another called it a long illness. Her obituary named six surviving children: daughters Eva Eytcheson of Augusta and Mabel Collins of Chelsea, and sons Clyde, Raymond, and Clifton of Augusta and George of Indiana.

Her funeral was held Tuesday afternoon at two o’clock from the Plummer Funeral Parlors, 16 Pleasant Street. The Rev. William R. Wood conducted the service. The newspaper noted the many relatives and friends present and the floral offerings placed around her casket.

Mabel was laid to rest in the family lot at Mount Hope Cemetery. Rev. Wood also conducted the committal service at the grave. Her bearers were her sons Clyde, George, and Raymond Simmons, together with L. E. Mitchell.

1926 death notice for Mabel Simmons naming the Old Britt House
The notice that anchors Mabel’s death to the Old Britt House and records a three-month illness.
1926 obituary for Mabel Simmons listing her surviving children
Mabel’s obituary preserves the names and locations of the six children who survived her.
Newspaper account of the funeral of Mabel Simmons
The funeral account records the service, family lot, flowers, and the men who carried her to rest.
Grave marker of Mabel I Simmons at Mount Hope Cemetery
Grave marker of Mabel I. Simmons at Mount Hope Cemetery, Augusta, Maine. Photograph by Peter Morgan, originally shared on Find a Grave memorial no. 125832596.
Her story did not end when the records fell silent.

Mabel’s life survives in a portrait, in the careful columns of census takers, in newspaper ink, in a stone at Mount Hope—and in the stories that followed her. Some questions may never be answered. Preserving them honestly is also a way of remembering.

Mabel Idella Bickford Simmons

Sources & Research Notes

A guide to the records used in this Memory Quilt

  • United States federal censuses for 1880, 1900, 1910, and 1920.
  • Lawrence, Massachusetts, city directory for 1907.
  • Massachusetts marriage index entry for Mabel Lanctot, Lawrence, 1913—retained as an unresolved lead.
  • Augusta municipal-court docket and contemporary Kennebec Journal coverage of the 1924 liquor case.
  • Daily Kennebec Journal death, obituary, and funeral notices, October 1926.
  • Mount Hope Cemetery grave marker; photograph by Peter Morgan, Find a Grave memorial no. 125832596.
  • Family research and oral tradition supplied by descendants; family lore is identified as such within the narrative.